Skip to content
Innovativity

Independent review of your S/4HANA Finance design before it goes to build

Your blueprint, read by someone who does not build it. Risk-ranked findings and a clear go or fix list, before the design becomes configuration. Including whether the design is ready for SAP's Joule agents, your own AI agents and hyperautomation.

What we review

  • Enterprise structure and chart of accounts
  • Finance integration with logistics, sales, procurement, production and projects (MM, SD, PP, PS, PM/CS)
  • Ledger design and parallel accounting (FI-GL)
  • Document splitting and Profit Center Accounting
  • Margin Analysis (CO-PA)
  • Product Costing and Material Ledger (CO-PC)
  • Overhead Controlling and allocations (CO-OM, PaPM)
  • Asset Accounting (FI-AA) and Investment Management
  • Intercompany billing, reconciliation (ICMR) and group reporting

Most of the findings come from the integration, not from the ledgers. The postings that break the first close are created in logistics, sales, procurement, production and projects, and Finance rarely reviews them.

Is your design ready for AI and hyperautomation?

SAP's Joule agents and your own agents build their proposals from your configuration and your posting history. A sound design lets you automate close, receivables and cash. A weak one repeats its gaps at machine speed. We check it in every review.

Information model

Every dimension an agent needs is posted on the Universal Journal line, not rebuilt in a spreadsheet.

Master data and governance

Owned, clean and consistent, because an agent acts on what it finds.

Standard before custom

Processes and interfaces stay close to standard, so SAP's Joule agents and your own can reach them. We check the release and functional choices each agent on your roadmap depends on.

Controls an agent can respect

Approvals, authorizations and segregation of duties are designed into the process, not kept in people's heads.

You get an AI and automation readiness verdict per area in the written opinion.

How the review runs

  1. 1Intake

    Documents and a call

    Blueprint, key design decision log and the open design questions, plus a call with the program lead and the SI's Finance lead.

  2. 2Review

    The whole value flow

    We read the Finance design against the whole value flow: enterprise structure, integration, ledgers, Margin Analysis, costing, intercompany.

  3. 3Findings session

    Agreed, not just listed

    Risk-ranked findings walked through with your program and your SI, so the fixes are agreed, not just listed.

  4. 4Written verdict

    A go or fix list

    A go or fix list in writing. Most review clients keep the seat afterwards.

    How a seat works

What we check, and when

The parts of the Finance design where programs lose data integrity and only find out at the first close. Most of those postings come from logistics, sales, procurement, production and projects, so we check the whole value flow, at the point where each decision is still cheap to change.

  1. Explore · Cheapest point to fix

    Design decisions

    Enterprise structure, chart of accounts, ledger model, document splitting, Margin Analysis.

    What the program produces

    • enterprise structure blueprint
    • chart of accounts and account groups
    • ledger and currency model
    • document splitting characteristics
    • operating concern and characteristics
    • key design decisions

    Where it goes wrong: decisions are taken module by module. The profit center and segment design follows the material master instead of how the business is steered, and the chart of accounts serves one country. Every later fix is a migration.

    What we check

    • Company code, plant, controlling area and operating concern assignments against the legal and the management structure
    • One operational chart of accounts, with group and country charts where local GAAP needs them
    • Profit center and segment design, functional areas, and the splitting characteristics with their zero-balance and mandatory settings
    • Leading, non-leading and extension ledgers, the accounting principle and the currency types each one carries
    • Margin Analysis characteristics and the derivation rules from customer, material and sales order
  2. Realize · Where we spend most review time

    Build and integration

    Account determination, costing, allocations, asset accounting, settlement.

    What the program produces

    • account determination
    • costing and valuation variants
    • allocation cycles
    • depreciation areas and asset classes
    • order types and settlement rules
    • results analysis

    Where it goes wrong: most postings in the Universal Journal are created by goods movements, invoices, deliveries, confirmations and settlements in MM, SD, PP, PS and PM/CS. Programs leave this to the logistics workstreams, and nobody checks that inventory, cost of sales and the P&L still agree.

    What we check

    • Account determination for goods movements, invoice verification and billing, valuation classes, price control per material type, and GR/IR clearing
    • Purchase order account assignment, invoice variances, accruals, consignment and subcontracting flows
    • Pricing conditions to revenue and deduction accounts, event-based revenue recognition, and the cost of goods sold split by cost component
    • Order types, work in process, variance categories, results analysis and settlement rules for production, PM/CS and WBS elements
    • Costing variants, the cost component structure, Material Ledger activation and the actual costing run
    • Assessment, distribution and activity allocation cycles, and which allocations run in universal allocation and which in PaPM
    • Depreciation areas per ledger, asset classes, capitalisation thresholds, assets under construction and investment orders
  3. Deploy · Hard to change after go-live

    Cutover and migration

    Open items, inventory values, open orders, fixed assets.

    What the program produces

    • migration objects and reconciliation reports
    • cutover plan
    • open item and balance migration
    • asset migration

    Where it goes wrong: open items land without document splitting, inventory migrates without its Finance values, and the first balance sheet by segment does not reconcile. Nobody notices until the period is closed.

    What we check

    • Migration of open items with document splitting active, so the first balance sheet by segment reconciles
    • Open purchase orders, sales orders, production orders and inventory values migrated with their Finance values intact
    • Asset migration per depreciation area and accounting principle
    • Fiscal year variants, posting periods and the close steps that depend on them
  4. First close · Here is where programs find out

    The first close

    Period-end sequence, intercompany, group reporting.

    What the program produces

    • the first month-end
    • intercompany reconciliation
    • the feed to group consolidation

    Where it goes wrong: every earlier shortcut surfaces here, at once. Intercompany loses days, segment reporting turns into a monthly reconciliation exercise, and the close becomes a search instead of a schedule.

    What we check

    • The period-end sequence: foreign currency valuation, reclassification, accruals and the allocation run order
    • Intercompany billing and the partner assignment on every intercompany posting, so eliminations work
    • Matching and reconciliation (ICMR) rules, matching methods and the reconciliation calendar inside the close
    • The feed to SAP Group Reporting or the consolidation system: financial statement items, consolidation units and the mapping
    • Inventory, cost of sales and the P&L reconciled to each other and to the logistics documents

These checks are also the catalogue our Review Engine runs on every tollgate set, with every finding verified by a named architect before it reaches you. The portal behind the seat

What we review, by SAP area

The full list by SAP area, from enterprise structure to group reporting.

Enterprise structure and chart of accounts

The frame everything else hangs on: company codes, plants, sales and purchasing organisations on the logistics side; controlling area, operating concern, profit centers, segments and functional areas on the Finance side; and one chart of accounts that serves group reporting and local statutory needs. Get this wrong and every later fix is a migration.

What we check

  • Company code, plant, controlling area and operating concern assignments against the legal and the management structure
  • One operational chart of accounts, with group and country charts where local GAAP needs them, account groups, and the account types for primary and secondary costs
  • Profit center and segment design that follows how the business is steered, not the material master
  • Functional areas for cost of sales reporting and the dimensions every planned report needs
Finance integration with logistics, sales, procurement, production and projects

Most postings in the Universal Journal are created by goods movements, invoices, deliveries, confirmations and settlements in MM, SD, PP, PS and PM/CS, not by Finance. Programs leave this to the logistics workstreams and find out at the first close that inventory, cost of sales and the P&L do not agree. This is where we spend most of our review time.

What we check

  • Account determination for goods movements, invoice verification and billing, valuation classes, price control per material type, and GR/IR clearing
  • Procure to pay: purchase order account assignment, invoice variances, accruals, and consignment and subcontracting flows
  • Order to cash: pricing conditions to revenue and deduction accounts, event-based revenue recognition for sales orders, projects and services, and the cost of goods sold split
  • Production, plant maintenance and projects: order types, work in process, variance categories, results analysis and settlement rules for production, PM/CS and WBS elements
  • Cut-over: how open purchase orders, sales orders, production orders and inventory values migrate with their Finance values intact
General Ledger and ledgers (FI-GL)

The Universal Journal is one table; the ledgers on top of it decide what each stakeholder sees. Parallel accounting for IFRS and local GAAP, the leading and non-leading ledgers, extension ledgers, and the currencies and fiscal year variants each ledger carries.

What we check

  • Leading and non-leading ledgers, extension ledgers for management adjustments, and the accounting principle each one carries
  • Currency types per ledger and company code, with group and functional currencies where consolidation and reporting need them
  • Fiscal year variants, posting periods and the close steps that depend on them: foreign currency valuation, reclassification, accruals
  • Open item management, clearing and the period-end sequence, so the close is a schedule rather than a search
Document splitting and Profit Center Accounting

Document splitting is what makes a balance sheet by profit center or segment possible, and it is close to impossible to change after go-live. The characteristics, the zero-balance rules and the profit center derivation decide whether segment reporting is real or a reconciliation exercise every month.

What we check

  • Splitting characteristics, with the zero-balance and mandatory settings per characteristic
  • Item categories, business transaction variants and constants for the document types that carry the split: invoices, payments, clearings
  • Profit center derivation from material, cost object, sales order and asset, with the defaults and substitutions that catch the rest
  • Migration of open items with document splitting active, so the first balance sheet by segment reconciles
Margin Analysis (CO-PA)

Margin Analysis lives in the Universal Journal, so the design is about which characteristics and derivations exist and how cost reaches the margin. The question is whether margin reporting matches how the business sells and steers: by customer, product, channel, region or project.

What we check

  • Operating concern, characteristics and derivation rules from the customer master, the material master and the sales order
  • Cost of goods sold split by cost component, and the attribution of price differences and production variances to the margin
  • How overhead reaches the margin: top-down distribution, assessment to profitability segments, and the realignment strategy
  • Account-based Margin Analysis as the basis, and what, if anything, still needs costing-based CO-PA next to it
Product Costing and Material Ledger (CO-PC)

Standard costs set inventory values and the margin; actual costing decides whether the P&L shows what production really cost. Costing variants, the cost component structure and the Material Ledger are where manufacturers find the surprises at the first close.

What we check

  • Costing variants, valuation variants, the costing sheet for overhead and the cost component structure
  • Price control per material type, Material Ledger activation and the actual costing run
  • Work in process, variance categories and settlement of production and process orders
  • Co-products, by-products, subcontracting and intercompany stock transfers, including group valuation and transfer prices where they apply
Overhead Controlling and allocations (CO-OM, PaPM)

Cost centers, internal orders and the allocation cycles that move cost to where the business wants to see it. When allocations get complex, SAP Profitability and Performance Management (PaPM) takes over, and the design has to say what runs where and how the two reconcile.

What we check

  • Cost center standard hierarchy, cost center categories, activity types and the planning approach
  • Assessment, distribution and activity allocation cycles, sender and receiver rules, and their run order in the close
  • Internal orders and statistical orders, settlement rules and receivers
  • Which allocations run in universal allocation and which in PaPM, with the reconciliation between them
Asset Accounting (FI-AA) and Investment Management

Asset Accounting posts per ledger, so depreciation areas must line up with the accounting principles. Capitalisation rules, assets under construction, investment orders and projects decide how CAPEX reaches the balance sheet and how it is reported before it does.

What we check

  • Chart of depreciation, depreciation areas per ledger and accounting principle, and the posting of parallel valuations
  • Asset classes, account determination, capitalisation thresholds and low-value asset rules per country
  • Assets under construction, investment orders and WBS elements with settlement to fixed assets
  • Investment programs and budgeting where Investment Management is in scope, and intercompany asset transfers
Intercompany billing, reconciliation (ICMR) and group reporting

Intercompany is where most closes lose days. The value flows between company codes, intercompany billing, matching and reconciliation, and the feed to group consolidation decide whether the group close is a process or a rescue.

What we check

  • Intercompany scope: stock transfers, drop shipments, services, cost and asset transfers, with pricing and tax treatment per flow
  • Intercompany billing and the partner assignment on every intercompany posting, so eliminations work
  • Matching and reconciliation (ICMR) rules, matching methods and the reconciliation calendar inside the close
  • The feed to SAP Group Reporting or the consolidation system: financial statement items, consolidation units and the mapping

What you get

  • A written report with findings ranked by risk
  • A challenge session on the key design decisions with your team and your System Integrator
  • A go or fix list per finding
  • A follow-up on the fixes before build starts

When it fits

At the end of the Explore or blueprint phase, before Realize. Before a wave or country rollout that reuses the template. After a go-live that did not deliver the numbers, before the next release.

After the review

Most review clients keep the seat. The review is the audition; the Quality Assurance seat is how the design stays right through build, test and the first close.

How a seat works

What clients say

I have hired Uğur as S/4HANA expert on our migration project for the Corporate SAP environment. Together with our business and IT architects, he worked on the projects pre-study and detailed out the as-is and to-be situations. Together with his Air France colleague Uğur was responsible for leading the RFI process for our integrator selection.

Richard van der Laan, Group Controller Maintenance and Program Director SAP MRO, Air France-KLM

Get the design read before it is built